Other recent F1000 evaluations

I have not recently updated my blog to include my F1000 evaluations; I now include these missing evaluations here for the benefit of those who do not subscribe to F1000. All of the following were first published on F1000 Prime in the last 12 months.

The GTPase IFT27 is involved in both anterograde and retrograde intraflagellar transport.

Huet D, Blisnick T, Perrot S, Bastin P. elife 2014; 3:e02419 PMID: 24843028 DOI: 10.7554/eLife.02419.001

This fascinating paper exploits Trypanosomes as a model system to define a role for the intraflagellar transport (IFT) protein IFT27 in flagellar function. IFT27 is a known component of the IFT-B particle mediating transport from the flagellar base to tip (anterograde IFT); here, the authors show that the GTPase function of IFT27 is also required to load the retrograde IFT particle (IFT-A) and its associated motor (dynein-2) into cilia. As such, this work defines IFT27 as a critical control point not only for anterograde but also for retrograde IFT. A key point is that IFT27 is a small Rab-like GTPase, and the authors convincingly demonstrate a role for this enzyme activity in the transport process. In some ways this provides further analogy between IFT-mediated transport and canonical membrane trafficking steps in which Rab proteins have critical roles in controlling timing and directionality.


Proteins of the Ciliary Axoneme Are Found on Cytoplasmic Membrane Vesicles during Growth of Cilia.

Wood CR, Rosenbaum JL. Curr Biol 2014 May 19; 24(10):1114-20 PMID: 24814148 DOI: 10.1016/j.cub.2014.03.047

This paper provides good evidence that structural proteins of the ciliary axoneme are transported into cilia on vesicular structures. Using Chlamydomonas as a model system, the data show that axonemal components and intraflagellar transport (IFT) particle proteins are delivered to the base of cilia on the surface of vesicles. These then associate with transitional fibres at the point of contact with the cell membrane. The process is particularly evident during cilia formation when a burst of synthesis of the ciliary components must be matched by an upregulation of their delivery. The work suggests an important and ongoing association of axonemal proteins with membranes. This and other work also support the maintained association of IFT proteins with membranes during transport within the cilium. This is therefore a significant paper in that it provides an integrated model for the transport of both membrane and axonemal proteins into cilia.


SNARE and regulatory proteins induce local membrane protrusions to prime docked vesicles for fast calcium-triggered fusion.

Bharat TA, Malsam J, Hagen WJ, Scheutzow A, Söllner TH, Briggs JA. EMBO Rep 2014 Mar 1; 15(3):308-14 PMID: 24493260 DOI: 10.1002/embr.201337807

The paper provides strong supporting evidence in favour of a membrane deformation event early in soluble N-ethylmaleimide-sensitive factor attachment protein receptor (SNARE)-dependent fusion. I concur entirely with what has already been said by Liangyi Chen and Junmei Fan and especially by Robert Burgoyne in his evaluation. Providing a mechanistic basis for some early electron microscopy (EM) is a lovely way to close the loop.


An Unconventional Secretory Pathway Mediates the Cilia Targeting of Peripherin/rds.

Tian G, Ropelewski P, Nemet I, Lee R, Lodowski KH, Imanishi Y. J Neurosci 2014 Jan 15; 34(3):992-1006 PMID: 24431457 DOI: 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.3437-13.2014

This paper provides some further evidence for the somewhat controversial idea of a non-conventional secretion pathway operating from the early secretory pathway to the cilium. Evidence on this originally came from the Witzgall lab looking at the trafficking of polycystin-2 {1}. Here, the authors use cell culture models and Xenopus to show that Peripherin-2/rds seems to be trafficked in a similar manner. Key evidence for this comes from glycosylation assays monitoring sensitivity to endoglycosidase H (EndoH). Canonical trafficking of glycoproteins results in an acquisition of EndoH resistance as a result of sugar chain modification in the Golgi. While there is some potential for slightly different interpretations, the data are broadly consistent with the idea of a non-canonical pathway operating in the delivery of cargo to the cilium.


Polycystin-2 takes different routes to the somatic and ciliary plasma membrane.

Hoffmeister H, Babinger K, Gürster S, Cedzich A, Meese C, Schadendorf K, Osten L, de Vries U, Rascle A, Witzgall R. J Cell Biol 2011 Feb 21; 192(4):631-45 PMID: 21321097 DOI: 10.1083/jcb.201007050


A Regulator of Secretory Vesicle Size, Kelch-Like Protein 12, Facilitates the Secretion of Apolipoprotein B100 and Very-Low-Density Lipoproteins.

Butkinaree C, Guo L, Ramkhelawon B, Wanschel A, Brodsky JL, Moore KJ, Fisher EA. Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol 2013 PMID: 24334870 DOI: 10.1161/ATVBAHA.113.302728

This article is important in that it extends our understanding of the molecular mechanisms governing the formation of large COPII vesicles at the endoplasmic reticulum (ER). Previously, the Rape lab has shown that the ubiquitin conjugation cofactor Klhl12 is required for the COPII-dependent formation of procollagen containing carriers {1}, likely through ubiquitylation of the outer layer COPII subunit Sec31. Here, Fisher and colleagues show that another atypically large cargo, apolipoprotein particles, also require Klhl12. While the paper does not fully explore the similarities or potential differences in mechanisms, the data do support a role for Klhl12 more generally in the export of unusually large cargo from the ER.


Ubiquitin-dependent regulation of COPII coat size and function.

Jin L, Pahuja KB, Wickliffe KE, Gorur A, Baumgärtel C, Schekman R, Rape M. Nature 2012 Feb 23; 482(7386):495-500 PMID: 22358839 DOI: 10.1038/nature10822


Microtubules that form the stationary lattice of muscle fibers are dynamic and nucleated at Golgi elements.

Oddoux S, Zaal KJ, Tate V, Kenea A, Nandkeolyar SA, Reid E, Liu W, Ralston E. J Cell Biol 2013 Oct 28; 203(2):205-13 PMID: 24145165 DOI: 10.1083/jcb.201304063

This article shows that static Golgi elements in flexor digitorum brevis (FDB) muscle fibers organize the microtubule network. The surprising finding is that this is not through a Golgi-nucleated microtubule mechanism involving proteins such as AKAP450 and GCC185 but instead through centrosomal proteins pericentrin and gamma-tubulin.
These experiments stemmed from the observation of microtubule bundles in these cells where an apparently stable microtubule lattice was seen to be decorated with dynamic EB3 puncta along their length. EB3 is known to only decorate growing microtubule ends. This was then explained through the good use of super-resolution microscopy (in this case gated stimulated emission depletion [GSTED]). Here, Oddoux and colleagues showed the presence of microtubule bundles emanating from clearly definable hubs. These hubs turned out to be Golgi elements, nucleating new microtubules which then grew alongside pre-existing ones. These in vitro data are also supported by in vivo data from intravital imaging. These experiments convincingly demonstrate the relevance of these findings in vivo.

The data are very carefully quantified and present a compelling case. The story adds nicely to our understanding of the relationship between the Golgi and centrosomal proteins in an interesting and important model system. The authors are now also well placed to determine the relevance of this organization and these mechanisms to Duchenne muscular dystrophy where loss of microtubule organization is thought to underlie the disease pathology {1}.


Microtubules underlie dysfunction in duchenne muscular dystrophy.

Khairallah RJ, Shi G, Sbrana F, Prosser BL, Borroto C, Mazaitis MJ, Hoffman EP, Mahurkar A, Sachs F, Sun Y, Chen YW, Raiteri R, Lederer WJ, Dorsey SG, Ward CW. Sci Signal 2012; 5(236):ra56  PMID: 22871609 DOI: 10.1126/scisignal.2002829


Asymmetric inheritance of centrosome-associated primary cilium membrane directs ciliogenesis after cell division.

Paridaen JTML, Wilsch-Bräuninger M, Huttner WB. Cell 2013 Oct 10; 155(2):333-44 PMID: 24120134 DOI: 10.1016/j.cell.2013.08.060

This is one of those papers that has such a simple underpinning observation that one wonders how it has not been seen before. The authors identify an Arl13b-positive membrane that is endocytosed from the primary cilium as the cell enters mitosis. This associates selectively with the mother centriole and gives this a head-start in terms of ciliogenesis and therefore in the ability to respond to sonic hedgehog signals. The paper demonstrates this in a number of different ways, both in vitro and in vivo, and shows some evidence for the importance of this asymmetric ciliogenesis in stem cell function.
Many questions remain as a result of this work. The evidence here strongly supports a model where this internalized Arl13b-positive membrane acts as a primer for ciliogenesis. Not only will it be important to define how this selective association occurs but whether and how selective biosynthetic trafficking to this compartment reinforces this process to drive subsequent cilia formation on exit from mitosis. I strongly recommend a look at the accompanying mini-review from Hoerner and Stearns as well {1}.


Remembrance of cilia past. Hoerner C, Stearns T. Cell 2013 Oct 10; 155(2):271-3 PMID: 24120128 DOI: 10.1016/j.cell.2013.09.027


Cerebral organoids model human brain development and microcephaly.

Lancaster MA, Renner M, Martin CA, Wenzel D … Homfray T, Penninger JM, Jackson AP, Knoblich JA.  Nature 2013 Sep 19; 501(7467):373-9 PMID: 23995685 DOI: 10.1038/nature12517

This is an outstanding manuscript that demonstrates not only the development of a system to model the human brain in vitro but also then applies this technique to prove that it can model complex human brain diseases. The authors develop what they term ‘cerebral organoids’ through differentiation of human pluripotent stem cells in a 3D culture system. They also develop organoids from patient-derived stem cells to show that the observed microcephaly caused by mutation in CDK5RAP2 is recapitulated in this system. The microcephaly phenotype is also evident after short hairpin RNA (shRNA) knockdown of CDK5RAP2, further demonstrating the applicability of this method. This paper provides an outstanding example for teaching purposes and of course will likely be widely applied to human developmental brain disorders.


A conserved role for atlastin GTPases in regulating lipid droplet size.

Klemm RW, Norton JP, Cole RA, Li CS … Farese RV Jr, Blackstone C, Guo Y, Mak HY.  Cell Rep 2013 May 30; 3(5):1465-75 PMID: 23684613 DOI: 10.1016/j.celrep.2013.04.015

The concept that atlastin is important for lipid metabolism raises new questions about the way that mutations in this protein cause human disease. The paper also points to a key link between endoplasmic reticulum morphology and lipid droplet biogenesis, which could have important implications for many other studies in this field.


ER exit sites are physical and functional core autophagosome biogenesis components.

Graef M, Friedman JR, Graham C, Babu M, Nunnari J. Mol Biol Cell 2013 PMID: 23904270 DOI: 10.1091/mbc.E13-07-0381

This paper convincingly identifies a key role for endoplasmic reticulum (ER) exit sites (ERESs) in autophagosome formation in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. These data show that autophagosomes form in close proximity to these specialised invaginations of the ER where COPII vesicles assemble.

Using a broad-ranging forward proteomics approach, Graef et al. defined multiple protein-protein interactions between autophagy proteins and vesicle trafficking proteins, most notably those that comprise the COPII coat. Key interactions were defined between COPII and proteins of the PI3-kinase and Atg9 complexes that initiate autophagosome formation. It is notable that the Sec23 subunit of the COPII coat appears to be at the hub of this network of interactions. This subunit also interacts with other key cellular machineries directing multiple functions of COPII and ensuring a directional flow to traffic (see {1}). Fluorescence imaging showed that early autophagosome structures formed adjacent to ERESs. Consistent with a key role for ERESs in this process, inhibiting ERES function using a temperature-sensitive form of Sec12 inhibited autophagic flux.

The authors conclude that ERESs act in the mechanical process of ERS formation and suggest that one role could be to tether the nascent autophagosome as it expands. While it is not yet clear exactly how ERESs function in autophagosome formation, the work places ERESs as acting downstream of Atg1 kinase complex localisation and speculate that ERESs provide membrane, and/or somehow scaffold, autophagosome assembly.

Interestingly, the authors extended their findings to higher eukaryotic cells, showing similar co-localisation between autophagy components and ERESs (labelled with mCherry-Sec16B) in Cos-7 cells. Exactly how ERESs direct autophagosome assembly, the identity of the proposed ERES-tether complex, and how the autophagosome is eventually released from its association with the ER remain to be defined.


Coordination of COPII vesicle trafficking by Sec23. Fromme JC, Orci L, Schekman R. Trends Cell Biol 2008 Jul; 18(7):330-6 PMID: 18534853 DOI: 10.1016/j.tcb.2008.04.006



Comments on: Synergy between XMAP215 and EB1 increases microtubule growth rates to physiological levels

I made some comments on this article for F1000Prime. The original evaluation can be found at: http://f1000.com/prime/718009660
he DOI for the original post is 10.3410/f.718009660.793476858

M Zanic, PO Widlund, AA Hyman and J Howard (2013) Synergy between XMAP215 and EB1 increases microtubule growth rates to physiological levels.
Nat Cell Biol  DOI: 10.1038/ncb2744
PMID: 23666085

This article provides clear insight into how microtubule polymerization rates are achieved in vivo. Rates from assays of in vitro microtubule polymerization are typically slow. Here, the authors achieve in vitro rates of up to 20 μm .min¯¹, which is around the highest that is seen in live cells. The key seems to be an allosteric interaction between the microtubule polymerase XMAP215 and the plus-end binding protein EB1. It is interesting to see that this interaction is not a conventional EB1-directed plus-end binding event but is, in fact, allosteric with the combination of EB1 and XMAP215 promoting polymerization. Using mathematical modelling, the authors also suggest that this synergistic step is in the final addition of the tubulin dimer to the existing lattice, an isomerization step where a loosely bound dimer becomes tightly bound. This work also contrasts with other work reconstituting the Drosophila microtubule polymerization machinery which implicated another protein, Sentin, in this process of rapid microtubule polymerization {1}. The data presented in this paper do not support a role for Sentin in the vertebrate system described here. The definition of the minimal components needed for rapid microtubule growth now provides the opportunity to integrate other components of the regulatory network controlling microtubule dynamics to provide a complete picture of the control of this process.

{1} Reconstitution of dynamic microtubules with Drosophila XMAP215, EB1, and Sentin.
Li W, Moriwaki T, Tani T, Watanabe T, Kaibuchi K, Goshima G.
J Cell Biol 2012 Nov 26; 199(5):849-62PMID: 23185033 DOI: 10.1083/jcb.201206101

Comments on: Silencing of mammalian Sar1 isoforms reveals COPII-independent protein sorting and transport

Vicky Miller (Postdoc in the Stephens lab) and I (David) have written the following comments on this paper that also appear on the Faculty of 1000 site. Vicky is also on Twitter @Dr_VickyMiller

Silencing of mammalian Sar1 isoforms reveals COPII-independent protein sorting and transport.

Cutrona MB, Beznoussenko GV, Fusella A, Martella O, Moral P, Mironov AA.

Traffic 2013; DOI: 10.1111/tra.12060 PMID: 23433038

This paper describes studies of trafficking of secretory cargo from the ER in cells depleted of the small GTPase Sar1, an essential component of the COPII coat. A COPII-independent mechanism of secretory trafficking would mark a step-change in our understanding of secretory protein trafficking in cells. While we do not think that this paper requires such a re-evaluation of our thinking, it does provide some thought provoking data. By disrupting the normal mechanism of transport the authors seek to reveal COPII-independent mechanisms and challenge the primacy of COPII-dependent transport. The most important point to bear in mind when reading this paper is that siRNA knock-downs are unable to generate a complete depletion of any protein and that residual Sar1 may influence some of the results seen. Indeed in our opinion, one cannot conclusively draw the conclusion that COPII-independent ER export pathways exist in cells from this work alone.

The authors confirm that Sar1-depletion effectively inhibits COPII vesicle formation (demonstrated by EM and reduced immunofluorescence staining of COPII components). They see changes to both ER-Golgi intermediate compartment (ERGIC) formation (the compartment between the Golgi and the ER) and Golgi organisation (resulting in formation of mini-stacks), also in agreement with a reduction in secretory trafficking. Despite this, pulse-chase experiments show no reduction in the total amount of protein secretion in Sar1-depleted cells. From this, the authors conclude that alternative transport mechanisms are being used. The virus glycoprotein VSV-G also passes from the ER to the plasma membrane in Sar1-depleted cells, even when additionalCOPII subunits (Sec23A and B) are depleted in addition to Sar1A and B. Based on these and other experiments, the authors propose a COPI-dependent replacement pathway that takes VSV-G to the Golgi. Export of procollagen transport is inhibited by Sar1-depletion, but as collagens require specialized COPII-coated vesicles to accommodate their large size, they therefore are not representative of typical COPII trafficking (Jin et al., 2012). Furthermore, many other studies support the notion that procollagen secretion is exquisitely sensitive to perturbation of the early secretory pathway (Smits et al., 2010; Townley et al., 2008; Venditti et al., 2012). 

These data do support the concept of a “short-loop” ER-to-Golgi trafficking pathway that involves juxtanuclear ER and possible even ER-Golgi contact sites. It is as yet unclear how possible mechanisms such as kiss and run could retainsufficient selectivity to prevent non-selective transport. It remains possible however that the small remaining amount of COPII proteins in the RNAi experiments described here is sufficient to direct COPII-dependent selectivity.

In summary the paper presents some interesting findings. Complete removal of Sar1 from cells by gene deletion is required to examine fully the existence ofCOPII-independent trafficking pathways and the relative importance of COPII-trafficking in cells. 


Jin, L., K.B. Pahuja, K.E. Wickliffe, A. Gorur, C. Baumgärtel, R. Schekman, and M. Rape. 2012. Ubiquitin-dependent regulation of COPII coat size and function. Nature 482(7386):495-500. doi: 10.1038/nature10822

Smits, P., A.D. Bolton, V. Funari, M. Hong, E.D. Boyden, L. Lu, D.K. Manning, N.D. Dwyer, J.L. Moran, M. Prysak, B. Merriman, S.F. Nelson, L. Bonafe, A. Superti-Furga, S. Ikegawa, D. Krakow, D.H. Cohn, T. Kirchhausen, M.L. Warman, and D.R. Beier. 2010. Lethal skeletal dysplasia in mice and humans lacking the golginGMAP-210. N. Engl. J. Med. 362:206-216.

Townley, A.K., Y. Feng, K. Schmidt, D.A. Carter, R. Porter, P. Verkade, and D.J. Stephens. 2008. Efficient coupling of Sec23-Sec24 to Sec13-Sec31 drives COPII-dependent collagen secretion and is essential for normal craniofacial development. J. Cell Sci. 121:3025-3034.

Venditti, R., T. Scanu, M. Santoro, G. Di Tullio, A. Spaar, R. Gaibisso, G.V. Beznoussenko, A.A. Mironov, A. Mironov, Jr., L. Zelante, M.R. Piemontese, A. Notarangelo, V. Malhotra, B.M. Vertel, C. Wilson, and M.A. De Matteis. 2012. Sedlin controls the ER export of procollagen by regulating the Sar1 cycle. Science. 337:1668-1672.

Full disclosure: David is a member of the “Traffic” editorial board but had not role in the editing or reviewing of this paper.

These comments are also published on F1000 Prime

Comments on: The Microtubule-Binding Protein Ensconsin Is an Essential Cofactor of Kinesin-1.

I evaluated the following article for F1000 Prime.

The Microtubule-Binding Protein Ensconsin Is an Essential Cofactor of Kinesin-1.

Barlan K, Lu W, Gelfand VI.

Curr Biol 2013 PMID: 23394833 DOI: 10.1016/j.cub.2013.01.008

This paper defines the microtubule binding protein ensconsin as an obligate co-factor for kinesin-1 drive in motility in Drosophila. In a series of elegant experiments, the authors show that ensconsin is not required for the recruitment of kinesin to membranes but is in some way involved in activating the motor. Ensconsin does not seem to affect the amount of membrane-bound kinesin in cells so the authors sought to define its role in motor activation. Kinesin-1 normally exists in an auto-inhibited confirmation in cells. In a key experiment the authors showed that removal of this auto-inhibition within the kinesin-1 motor by mutation eliminates the requirement for ensoconsin in vivo. These data suggest a model in which ensconsin acts to relieve the auto-inhibition. An important point is that this function of ensconsin did not require its own microtubule binding activity. The authors postulate that spatial restriction of ensconsin to microtubules acts to refine the spatial activation of kinesin-1, adding to the diversity of mechanisms that control the spatial and temporal organization of microtubule motor activation.

Note: Ensconsin is also known as E-MAP-115 and MAP7.

These comments also appear on Faculty of 1000 Prime

Dynein alone?

I evaluated the following article for F1000:

Dynein light chain 1 and a spindle-associated adaptor promote dynein asymmetry and spindle orientation.
AK Dunsch, D Hammond, J Lloyd, L Schermelleh, U Gruneberg and FA Barr J Cell Biol. 2012 Sep 17; 198(6): 1039-54
PMID: 22965910 DOI: 10.1083/jcb.201202112

The thing that fascinates me the most about this is the possibility that dynein containing light chain-1 acts without dynactin…..hence the crap title for the post.

This paper is highly intriguing from a dynein motor perspective as it strongly suggests that, in mitosis, the binding of dynein light chain 1 (DYNLL1) and the major dynein regulator dynactin are mutually exclusive. The work details very clearly how the adaptor proteins CHICA and HMMR target dynein to the mitotic spindle. This serves to control spindle positioning in cells, at least in part through promoting dynein asymmetry. It will be fascinating to determine whether DYNLL1 and dynactin can bind to dynein at the same time in interphase cells; this would of course have major implications for those studying dynein and dynactin function.

Evaluated: Trichoplein and Aurora A block aberrant primary cilia assembly in proliferating cells.

I evaluated this paper for Faculty of 1000:

A Inoko,M Matsuyama,H Goto,Y Ohmuro-Matsuyama,Y Hayashi,M Enomoto,M Ibi,T Urano,S Yonemura,T Kiyono,I Izawa,M Inagaki
Trichoplein and Aurora A block aberrant primary cilia assembly in proliferating cells.
J Cell Biol 2012 197
PMID: 22529102 DOI: 10.1083/jcb.201106101

I really liked this paper as it provides a simple outcome through very thorough data. The work here shows that trichoplein acts to suppress the formation of primary cilia by activating the protein kinase Aurora A at centrosomes. Suppression of trichoplein expression using RNA interference (RNAi) induces the formation of cilia in cells that would not normally form these structures. As one might expect from this, overexpression of trichoplein prevents cilia formation in quiescent cells.

This work builds nicely on previous findings showing that trichoplein is recruited to centrioles by ODF2 {1} where it drives recruitment of ninein. Previous data have also shown that trichoplein regulates the contacts between the endoplasmic reticulum and mitochondria. It will be interesting to define whether these activities are linked.

{1} Ibi M. et al (2011)Trichoplein controls microtubule anchoring at the centrosome by binding to Odf2 and ninein. J Cell Sci 124: 857-64

Evaluated: The Sec7 Arf-GEF Is Recruited to the trans-Golgi Network by Positive Feedback.

Another Faculty of 1000 evaluation:

The Sec7 Arf-GEF Is Recruited to the trans-Golgi Network by Positive Feedback.

BC Richardson, CM McDonold, JC Fromme

Developmental Cell 2012 vol. 22 4

PMID: 22516198 DOI: 10.1016/j.devcel.2012.02.006

This paper sheds light on the complex issues of both how and where Arf proteins are activated. Here, the authors show that the Sec7 Arf-guanine nucleotide exchange factor (GEF) from yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) is recruited by its own product, activated Arf1, in a positive feedback loop. This suggests a means by which sustained activation can be achieved. Importantly the data are also consistent with models where Sec7 exists in an autoinhibited state that requires activation to drive guanine nucleotide exchange on Arf1. The HDS1 domain of Sec7 acts as a switch controlling activation where membrane association is the trigger for that switch. Arf1 interacts with the HDS1 domain to recruit Sec7 to membranes and this same domain is then required for subsequent rounds of Arf1 activation. The HDS1 domain also appears to play a key role in targeting Sec7 to the trans-Golgi network in S. cerevisiae. The authors propose that it is not recruited by Arf1 located at other parts of the Golgi because it is out-competed by COPI. Alternatively, one could envisage additional factors driving selective recruitment.

The principles defined for Arf1/Sec7 here have been shown previously to apply to other systems such as that of ARNO {1}. This work provides a substantial framework for analysis of the more complex situation in metazoans, notably mammals.


{1} Stalder D, Barelli H, Gautier R, Macia E, Jackson CL, Antonny B (2011) Kinetic studies of the Arf activator Arno on model membranes in the presence of Arf effectors suggest control by a positive feedback loop. J Biol Chem 286(5): 3873-83